The Effectiveness of Structured Teaching Programme on Knowledge regarding Ill effects of alcoholism among auto-rickshaw drivers.

 

Mr. Kiran N Hegade1, Mr. Veereshkumar Nandagaon2

1Senior Tutor, K.L.E.University’s Institute of Nursing Sciences, Belgavi, Karnataka.

2Asst. Professor, K.L.E.University’s Institute of Nursing Sciences, Belgavi, Karnataka.

*Corresponding Author Email: kiranhegdebgm@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

The objectives of the study were to assess the knowledge regarding ill effects of alcoholism among  auto-rickshaw drivers as measured by structured questionnaire, to evaluate the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on knowledge regarding ill effect of alcoholism among auto-rickshaw drivers, to find out an association between pre-test knowledge scores with selected demographic variables. The study was conducted using pre experimental: one group pre-test post-test design. Demographic variables analyzed for the study were age, religion, residence, marital status, type of family, education, income, years of driving auto-rickshaw, consumed alcohol, information regarding ill effects of alcoholism. The study was conducted on sample of 60  Auto-rickshaw drivers Belgaum city, Karnataka. Data collection was through structured knowledge questionnaire. Data obtained were tabulated and analyzed in terms of objectives of the study using descriptive and inferential statistics. The study findings showed that there is increase in post test knowledge scores regarding ill effects of alcoholism compared to pre test knowledge scores. The study concluded that the Structured Teaching Programme on ill effects of alcoholism was an effective method for providing average knowledge to good knowledge and help auto-rickshaw drivers to enhance their knowledge regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

 

KEYWORDS: Knowledge, Auto-rickshaw drivers, Ill effects of alcoholism.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

“First you take a drink, then the drink takes a drink, then the drink takes you.” 

Francis Scott Key Fitzgerald.

 

The word alcoholism and alcoholic were first used by Dr. Magnus Huss, a Swedish physician. Egyptian Osiris and Roman Bacchus were patrons of high power related to alcohol. The Bible sanctioned the social use of wine but it also records divine commands to abstain. There was a cultural attitude leaning more towards abstinence but permissive ritualistic sanctity of alcohol emerged in the later social structure. The utilitarian nature of alcoholism for pleasure and pain emerged during the twentieth century.

 

Late in the nineteenth century the temperance movement by lay people and the Church fought against alcoholism with a moralistic approach and started treating patients on spiritual grounds with confessions and conversions.1

 

In drunken driving, the main cause of accidents is that they don’t care about themselves and others. They have done it many times before and never had a problem, so they are willing to take a risk. Another cause of drunk driving is the difficulty in knowing your level of impairment after consuming a given quantity of alcohol. Alcohol slows down a person’s reflex and impairs their reasoning while deluding the drunken driver into believing they are competent to drive and their motor skills unaffected. Some of them reasons for drunken drink due to job stress, relaxation, family disharmony, pleasure, lack of control over alcohol, peer pressure.2

 

NEED FOR THE STUDY:

According to the statistical data collected by World Health Organization (WHO), somewhere around 76 million people across the world suffer from some or the other disorder which can be traced to alcohol abuse. With an estimated 100,000 deaths attributed to alcohol consumption every year, the scenario is not quite pleasant in the United States either. More importantly, this figure doesn't just include deaths as a result of some alcohol-related disorders (such as cirrhosis of the liver and cancer), but also includes indirect causes related to alcohol such as driving accidents, homicides.3

 

The health-related consequences created by alcoholism are very much disturbing to both individuals and the society. Alcohol is the third most common cause of death in developed countries. Worldwide alcohol causes 2.5 million deaths (3.8 % of total) and 69.4 million (4.5 % of total) of disability-adjusted life years. Unintentional injuries alone account for about one-third of the 2.5 million deaths, while neuro-psychiatric conditions account for close to 40% of the 69.4 million disability-adjusted life years.  Thus alcoholism has become one of the most important social issues all over the world.4

 

India has one of the highest road accident rates in the world. There has been a steady rise in the casualties in road accidents in the country and their proportions in total deaths due to all accident have also increased considerably in the past. In India, nearly 80,000 get killed and 340,000 are injured every year in about 300,000 accidents on road network of just 22,00,000 km. There is an accident every minute and death every 8 min. significant variations also arise between different states of India .5

 

Heavy drinking at the workplace may potentially lower productivity. Sickness absence associated with harmful use of alcohol and alcohol dependence entails a substantial cost to employees and social security systems. There is ample evidence that people with alcohol dependence and problem drinkers have higher rates of sickness absence than other employees.6

 

This practice of alcohol consumption is not only found widespread but also considered common by the auto-rickshaw drivers. On communicating, many of these drivers were found to be ignorant about the ill effects of Alcohol. So the investigator found that conducting a study and imparting knowledge on the ill effects of alcoholism  is necessary.  

 

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM:

A study to assess the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on knowledge regarding ill effects of alcoholism among auto-rickshaw drivers of  Belgaum city. Karnataka.

 

OBJECTIVES:

The objectives of the study are:

1.    To assess the knowledge regarding ill effects of alcoholism among auto-rickshaw drivers.

2.    To evaluate the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on knowledge regarding ill effect of alcoholism among auto-rickshaw drivers.

3.    To find out an association between pre-test knowledge scores with selected demographic variables.

 

Operational Definition:

1.    Assess: It means statistical measurement based on knowledge scores of auto-rickshaw drivers on ill effects of alcoholism through close ended questionnaire.

2.    Effectiveness: It means the improved knowledge scores after the administration of structured teaching programme regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

3.    Structured teaching programme: Lesson prepared by the investigator designed for the participants of the study, regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

4.    Knowledge: In this study it refers to information regarding ill effects of alcoholism among the auto-rickshaw drivers.

5.    Ill effects: Affected by an impairment of normal physical or mental health.

6.    Alcoholism: In this study it refers to dependence on alcohol that seriously interferes with life adjustment.

7.    Auto-rickshaw drivers: A person who has license to drive auto-rickshaw to earn his livelihood.

 

Hypothesis:

1.    H1: There will be significant difference in the pre-test and post-test knowledge  scores at 0.05 level of significance.

2.    H2: There will be a statistical association between pre-test knowledge scores and selected demographic variables at 0.05 level of significance

 

Assumptions:       

1.    Auto-rickshaw drivers may not have knowledge regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

2.     Auto-rickshaw drivers knowledge regarding the ill effects of alcoholism can be improved by administering a structured teaching programme.

 

Delimitation:

·      The study is limited to only Auto-rickshaw drivers of Belgaum city.

 

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:

Research approach:

In the present evaluative approach was used to assess the knowledge regarding the ill effects of alcoholism.

 

Research design:

Pre-experimental - one group   pre-test post-test research design was adopted to carry out the present study.

 

Variables: The variable for the present study are:

·      Independent variables:

·      Structured Teaching Programme on ill effects of alcoholism.

·      Dependent variables: Knowledge of auto-rickshaw drivers.

·      Extraneous variables: Personal characteristics which include age, education,     residence, religion, marriage, income, type of family, years of driving experience consumed alcohol and source of information regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

 

Population:

The population of the present study comprises Auto-rickshaw drivers of Belgaum City, Karnataka.

 

Sample size:

Sample size of the present study consists of 60 samples of auto-rickshaw drivers.

 

Sampling technique:

Non–probability Convenient sampling was used to select the samples for the study.

 

Sampling criteria:

Inclusion criteria:

·      Auto-rickshaw drivers willing to participate in the study.

·      Auto-rickshaw drivers present during the period of data collection.

·       Auto-rickshaw drivers above 18 years of age.

 

Exclusion criteria:

·      Auto-rickshaw drivers who are presently receiving treatment for alcoholism.

·      Auto-rickshaw drivers who are not willing to participate in the study.

·      Auto-rickshaw drivers below18 years of age.

 

Description of the tool:

The tool consists of:

Section I: Socio-demographic data containing 10 items.

Section II: Consists of 30 items (multiple choice questions) on ill effects of alcoholism.

 

Classification of knowledge score was done as shown below:

·      (X+SD) = Good knowledge Score

·      (X+SD) to (X-SD) = Average knowledge Score

·      (X-SD) = Poor knowledge Score

 

A score of ‘1’ was given to all correct answers while a score of ‘0’ was given to all incorrect answers.

 

Plan for Data Analysis:

The plan of analysis was as follows:

·      Organization of data in a master sheet

·      Tabulation of the data in terms of frequencies, percentage, to describe the data. Mean, median, mode, range and standard deviation computed for asses knowledge score.

 

Inferential statistics were used to draw the following conclusions:

·      Paired ‘t’ test to evaluate the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on knowledge regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

·      Chi-square (χ2) test was used to find out an association between knowledge scores and the selected demographic variables at 0.05 level of significance.

 

RESULTS:

Findings related to socio demographic variables.

Table no 1:Frequency and percentage distribution of auto-rickshaw drivers according to socio demographic variables. n = 60

S No.

Socio-demographic variables

Frequency

(f)

Percentage

(%)

1.

Age in years.

 

 

 

a.     Less than 20

6

10

 

b.     20-30

25

41.6

 

c.     31-40

14

23.4

 

d.     41-50

6

10

 

e.     51-60

7

11.6

 

f.      Above 60

2

3.4

2.

Residence

 

 

 

a.     Rural

03

5

 

b.     Urban

51

85

 

c.     Semi urban

06

10

3

Religion.

 

 

 

a.     Hindu.

35

58.3

 

b.     Muslim.

22

36.7

 

c.     Christian.

03

5

 

d.     Others.

00

00

4

Marital status

 

 

 

a.     Single

18

30

 

b.     Married

42

70

 

c.     Divorced

00

00

 

d.     Widower

00

00

5

Types of family

 

 

 

a.     Nuclear

13

21.7

 

b.     Joint

47

78.3

 

c.     Extended

00

00

6

Education

 

 

 

a.     Illiterate

04

6.7

 

b.     Primary School Education

26

43.3

 

c.     Secondary High  School Education

24

40

 

d.     Graduation

06

10

7

Income monthly in rupees

 

 

 

a.     Below2500

00

00

 

b.     25001-5000

38

63.3

 

c.     5001-10000

22

36.7

 

d.     More than10000

00

00

 

Table no. 1 continued

S No.

Socio-demographic variables

Frequency

(f)

Percentage

(%)

8

 

Years of driving Autorickshaw

 

 

 

a.     1-5yrs

10

16.7

 

b.     6-10yrs

26

43.3

 

c.     11-15yrs

18

30

 

d.     More than15yrs

06

10

9

Have you taken alcohol

 

 

 

a.     Yes

36

60

 

b.     No

24

40

10

Information about ill effects of alcoholism

 

 

 

a.     Yes

38

63.3

 

b.     No

22

36.7

 

Source of information

 

 

 

a.     Health personal

18

30

 

b.     Media

07

11.6

 

c.     Neighbors

00

00

 

d.     Friends

10

16.6

 

e.     Parents

3

5

 

The data presented in Table 1 indicates that,

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 25(41.6%) belonged to the age group 20-30 years, and minority 2(3.4%) belonged to the age group of above 60 years.

·      Majority of the  auto-rickshaw drivers were staying  in urban area 51(85%) and minority 3(5%)  were living in rural area.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 35(58.3%) were Hindus, 22(36.7%) were Muslims, while 3(5%) belonged to Christain religion, 0(0%) belonged to other category.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 42(70%) were Married,18 (30%) were Single, while 00(0%) belonged to Divorced and Widower.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 47(78.3%) were from Joint family and 13(21.7%) were from Nuclear family, while 00(0%) were from Extended family.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 26(43.3%) were Primary school education, 24(40%) were Secondary high school education,6(10%) were did Graduation and minority 4(6.7%) were Illiterate.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers according to their income per month shows that 38(63.3%) of samples had 2500-5000 Rs and 22(36.7%) of samples had 5001-10000 Rs and 00(0%) had Below 2500 Rs and More than 10000 Rs.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers according to their Years of driving       auto-rickshaw shows that 26(43.3%) of samples had 6-10 years, 18(30%) of sample 11-15years, remaining 10(16.7%) of sample had 1-5 years, and minority 6(10%) were more than 15 years.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 36(60%) had taken alcohol and remaining 24(40%) of sample said No they have not taken alcohol .

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers according to information about ill effects of alcoholism shows that 38(63.3%) of samples are belongs to Yes they have got the information and remaining 22(36.7%) were not got information.

·      Majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers according to source of information about ill effects of alcoholism shows that 18(30%) of samples source of information was health personnel, 10(16.6%) of samples source of information friends, 7(11.6%) of sample source of information was media,3(5%) of sample source of information was parents and 00(0%) of samples source of information was neighbors.

 

SECTION II: Findings related to knowledge of auto-rickshaw drivers regarding ill effect of alcoholism.

 

Table 2: Mean, Median, Mode, Standard deviation and range of knowledge scores of  auto-rickshaw drivers regarding ill effect of alcoholism.                                                                   n=60

Area

of

Analysis

Mean

Median

Mode

Standard

Deviation

(SD)

Range

Pre test

10.06

10

8.8

3.2

12

Post test

21.05

21

20.09

3.4

12

Difference

10.09

11

12.1

0.2

00

 

Table 2: reveals that difference between pre-test score and post-test score showed that over all difference in between pre-test and post-test in Mean was 10.09, Median was 11, Mode was 12.1, Standard deviation was 0.2 and Range was 00.


 

3.     Frequency (f) and Percentage (%) distribution of knowledge scores of auto-rickshaw drivers regarding ill effect of alcoholism.   n=60

Knowledge Scores

Pre test

Post test

 

Score range

f

%

Score range

f

%

Good(X+SD)

14-30

10

16.6

14-30

60

100

Average (X+SD to X-SD)

7-13

42

70

7-13

0

0

Poor(X-SD)

0-6

8

13.3

0-6

0

0

 

Table 3 reveals that in pre-test majority of auto-rickshaw drivers 42(70%) had average knowledge, 10(16.6%) had good knowledge and 8(13.3%) had poor knowledge. In the post-test 60 (100%) had good knowledge.

 

Table 4 Pre-test and post-test knowledge scores of auto-rickshaw drivers in items on ill effects of alcoholism.                                n=60

 

 

Mean % of Knowledge scores of auto-rickshaw drivers.

Sl.No

Items No.

Total score

Pre-test (x)%

Post-test (y)%

Gain in Knowledge (y-x)%

1.

Ill effects of Alcoholism

1800

33.55%

70.16%

36.61%

 

Table 4: reveals that there was 36.61% gain in knowledge among auto-rickshaw drivers on knowledge  regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

 

Figure 3 : Column graph representing gain in knowledge scores auto-rickshaw drivers regarding ill effects of alcoholism.

 

TESTING:

SECTION III: Testing of hypothesis for evaluation of effectiveness of structured teaching program for auto rickshaw drivers on knowledge regarding ill effect of alcoholism.

 

Table 5 : Mean difference (d), Standard error of difference (SED) and paired values of knowledge scores among auto-rickshaw drivers.   n=60

Mean Difference (d)

Standard Error Difference (SED)

Paired ‘t’ test values

Calculated

Tabulated value at 59 degrees of freedom

10.9

0.60

80.40*

1.96

*(P<0.05)

 

Table 5: reveals that calculated paired ‘t’ value (t=80.40) is greater than tabulated value(t= 1.96). Hence H1 is accepted. This indicates that the gain in knowledge score was statistically significant at P<0.05 level. Therefore structured teaching programme on ill effects of alcoholism is effective to improve the knowledge of the auto-rickshaw drivers.

 

Testing of Hypothesis

Association between the pre-test knowledge scores of auto- rickshaw drivers and demographic variables. 

H2: There will be a significant association between pre-test knowledge scores and selected demographic variables at 0.05 level of significance.

Table :Association between pre-test knowledge score and selected demographic variables .                                              n=60

S.

No

Socio demographic variables

Good

Average

Poor

χ2

CAL. VAL

χ2

TAB VAL

df

1.

Age in years.

a.     Less than 20

b.     20-30

c.     31-40

d.     41-50

e.     51-60

f.      Above 60

 

0

9

1

0

0

0

 

5

15

12

6

3

1

 

1

1

1

0

4

1

 

 

29.05*

 

 

18.30

 

 

10

 

2.

Residence

a.     Rural 

b.     Urban

c.     Semi Urban

 

0

10

0

 

1

36

5

 

2

5

1

 

9.2

(NS)

 

9.48

 

4

3.

Religion.

a.     Hindu.

b.     Muslim.

c.     Christian.

d.     Others.

 

6

4

0

0

 

26

13

3

0

 

3

5

0

0

 

 

3.84

(NS)

 

 

12.59

 

 

6

4.

Marital Status

a.     Single.

b.     Married.

c.     Divorced.

d.     Widower.

 

7

3

0

1

 

11

31

0

1

 

0

8

0

0

 

 

11.20

(NS)

 

 

12.59

 

 

6

5.

Types of family

a.     Nuclear

b.     Joint  

c.     Extended

 

0

10

0

 

11

31

5

 

2

6

0

 

 

3.20

(NS)

 

 

9.48

 

 

4

 

6.

Education

a.     Illiterate

b.     Primary School Education

c.     Secondary High   School Education

d.     Graduation

 

0

0

5

5

 

1

21

19

1

 

3

5

0

0

 

 

41.70*

 

 

 

12.59

 

 

6

 

7.

 

 

 

Income monthly in rupees

a.     Below 2500

b.     2501-5000

c.     5001-10000

d.     More than 10000

 

0

6

4

0

 

0

29

13

0

 

0

3

5

0

 

 

2.98

(NS)

 

 

 

12.59

 

 

 

 

6

8.

 

 

 

 

Years of driving autorickshaw

a.     1-5yrs

b.     6-10yrs

c.     11-15yrs

d.     More than 15yrs

 

2

8

0

0

 

7

16

15

4

 

1

2

3

2

 

 

20.06*

 

 

 

 

12.59

 

 

 

6

 

 

9.

 

 

 

Have you taken alcohol ?

a.     Yes

b.     No

a.      

 

5

5

 

 

26

16

 

 

5

3

 

 

0.49

(NS)

 

 

5.99

 

 

 

2

 

 

10.

 

 

Do you have any information about ill effects of alcoholism

b.     Yes

c.     No

 

7

3

 

27

15

 

4

4

 

0.82

(NS)

 

5.99

 

2

*=Significant association, NS=Non Significant association. df= degree of freedom.

 

 


The findings of the study reveals that chi-square calculated value is greater than chi-square table value so there is significant association between age in years, education status , years of driving auto-rickshaw and pre-test knowledge scores of auto- rickshaw drivers. Hence H2 is accepted.

 

 

Chi-square calculated value is less than chi-square table value so there is no significant association between residences, religion, marital status, types of family, income, consumption of alcohol, information about ill effects of alcoholism and pre- test knowledge scores of auto-rickshaw drivers. Hence H2 is rejected.

 

 

DISCUSSION:

Demographic variables (sample characteristics):

The data on sample characteristics revealed that majority of the auto-rickshaw drivers 25(41.6%) belonged to the age group 20-30 years.

 

The findings of the study was  supported by the study of  Millo T. Sharma ,RK. Murthy OP.et. al on incidence of alcohol use in road traffic accidents, India. The study revealed that 170 cases (34%) were positive for alcohol. The maximum cases (38.2%) belonged to the age group of 20-30 years.  The study concluded that there was a significant effect of alcohol consumption to road traffic accidents maximum cases (38.2%) belonged to the age group of 20-30 years.7

 

In the present study pre-test and the post-test data analysis revealed that the mean post test knowledge score 21.05%was higher than the mean pre-test knowledge score 10.06%, with the median 21,mode 20.09,standard deviation 3.4 and range 12. The calculated paired’ value [t= 80.40*] was higher than tabulated t value [t=1.90] which was statistically significant at P<0.05 level. Comparison of pre-test and post- test knowledge score regarding ill effects of alcoholism revealed that the STP was effective method in improving the knowledge of auto-rickshaw drivers.

 

A similar finding was observed by Brijesh Kumar, Ratna Prakash et al on Effectiveness of an awareness program about the harmful effects of tobacco and Alcohol on knowledge and self reported practice, Dehradun India. Result showed that  pretest and posttest knowledge score using paired t-test revealed that there was significant improvement in knowledge regarding harmful effects of alcohol and tobacco use (t=27.61, p=0.001). The study concluded that the awareness program resulted in significant improvement of knowledge about harmful effects of tobacco and alcohol use.8

 

CONCLUSION:

The findings of this study have implications for nursing practice, nursing education, nursing administration and nursing research. In the nursing curriculum now a day much emphasis is given on comprehensive care. So the study will help the teachers to educate the student and the staff nurses for increasing the knowledge about ill effects of alcoholism. The Structured Teaching Programme could help  nurse educator to use it as a tool for teaching. The present study can be a source of review of literature for others who are planning to conduct studies on the similar topics. The findings of the study can be presented in any conference and make the data available for other nurse researcher. Such studies must be conducted in various other settings.

 

REFERENCES:

1.     Vyas JN, Ahuja N. Textbook of postgraduate psychiatry.2nd ed Vol. 2.New Delhi. Jaypee Brothers publication;2008.p.789

2.      Understanding the causes of drunk driving at alcohol solutions. [Online]. Available from:URL:http://everettanalyzers.com/causes-of-drunk-driving. html

3.     Side Effects of Alcohol Abuse[Online];2013Mar.Available from: URL:http://www.buzzle.com/articles/side-effects-of-alcohol-abuse.html

4.     WHO.Globalstatusreportonalcoholism.[Online].Availablefrom:URLhttp://www.who.int/substanceabuse/facts/alcohol/en/index.htm.

5.     MohanD.Theroadahead:trafficinjuriesandfatalitiesinIndia:Indianinstituteoftechnology,Delhi;April2004.Availableat:URL:http://www.academia.edu/1402287/Road_safety_in_India_challenges and opportunities

6.     Klingemann H, Gmel G. Mapping the social consequences of alcohol consumption. Dordrecht: kluweracademicpublishers; 2001.Availablefrom:URL:www.who.int/...abuse/.../globalstatusreportalcohol2004_socproblems.pdf

7.     Millo T, Sharma RK, Murthy OP.et al. Incidence of alcohol use in road traffic accidents. Indian Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology 2008; Delhi.  2(1):1-6   

8.     Kumar B, Prakash R. Effectiveness of an Awareness Program about the Harmful Effects of Tobacco and Alcohol on Knowledge and Self Reported Practice of Adolescent Students Studying in a Selected School of Dehradun India. International Journal of Nursing Science. 2013; 3(3): 57-61. M Available from:URL:http://connection.ebscohost.com